not much of a Priest fan, but Spooky Tooth have to be the absolute hands down best thing I've found sort of via this place.
Spooky Two is brain meltingly good in places. This track in particular and Evil Woman, just make the mind boggle at how they could have been omitted from rock history as they seem to have been.
I'm the flip side of you: only a sorta-fan of Spooky Tooth, but a huge Priest fan (as you can see). However, we definitely agree on the songs from [i]Spooky Two[/i]: Better By You, Better Than Me and Evil Woman are definitely my two favs, and just as you describe!
And even though I'm only a sorta-fan I also agree with you on it being a shame they've been overlooked!