• Oasis_Ro

    fake ... so lame

    Mayo 2007
  • zackyv_x3

    i love their song 'hello'..<3

    Mayo 2007
  • Dorinda

    Last post (sorry): Now I don't want to discuss this anymore. We're not getting anywhere with this.

    Mayo 2007
  • Dorinda

    continuing: And I think that she should stop trying so hard to convince everyone that Ev is a band. That's partly the reason why I've lost my respect for her. Of course Amy is innocent when you believe in everything you read. No label would alow they're biggest commercial product getting it's rumour ruined. I've never said or meant that she's the only one there's something wrong with.

    Mayo 2007
  • Dorinda

    froskest: I didn't say that EVERYTHING is Amy's fault, but if you're smart enough to read just a bit between the lines there shouldn't be any problem seeing that there must be something wrong. Of course, we - the media and the fans, has NO idea what's actually going on. Do you really think they're telling us everything? About the Amy IS Evanescence-talk: I totally agree.

    Mayo 2007
  • fallenEpitaph

    so who are the new crew?

    Mayo 2007
  • coobymx

    Totally agree with Froskest! :D

    Mayo 2007
  • froskest

    Which she didn't. Amy have only fired one person. Will left because of his family, David because Evanescence was turning a bit away from being a christian band and Rocky of unknown reasons. Ben was the only one who left because of Amy. And John was the only one that got fired. She didn't kicked them all out of the band. Du-uh.

    Mayo 2007
  • froskest

    ... she is fully allowed to fire him. Though it's sad for the fans who liked him. Actually Rocky left already in January, but he decided to stay and finish the tour before he confirmed it to the fans. He wasn't allowed to say anything because of the contract with Wind Up. None knew of this before John said it when he was fired. This makes Amy look even more bad. Like she fired both of them.

    Mayo 2007
  • froskest

    @ Dorinda: I think it's pathetic to think that it's all Amy's fault. I know many people think it's wrong to say that Amy IS Evanescence. But guess what people. She IS. Neither John or Rocky have been with Evanescence since the beginning. It was only Ben and Amy. And when Ben left VOLUNTARY Amy got to own the whole band herself. If she didn't think that John was doing his job ..

    Mayo 2007
  • EvermoreRocks

    =)

    Mayo 2007
  • Thenightside

    Evanescence are a one-woman-'band' IMO :D

    Mayo 2007
  • Dorinda

    amyfan09: How many other bands change members once or twice every year? Of course there's something wrong. All the fans seem to worship Amy like a Goddess and always blames somebody else than her. Like everyone else are idiots and she's the little innocent one. I lost my respect for her a long time ago. In fact - I don't see Evanescence as a band anymore. I still love the music, though.

    Mayo 2007
  • chukemene

    Best wishes to Amy.

    Mayo 2007
  • froskest

    Looking forward to see who the next musicans will be.

    Mayo 2007
  • amyfan09

    why don't you fans stfu about amy. ben left because he was trying to control the band, will left because he wanted to be with his family, and for unkown reasons john was fired and rocky quit. so why is it that amy is the villian now? get more info before you point your finger.

    Mayo 2007
  • bleedingblack

    For the first time I wish ben to come back to Evanescence.

    Mayo 2007
  • Here_in_my_head

    I completely agree with HelloS1.

    Mayo 2007
  • amyfan09

    john was fired and rocky quit. i'm not gonna jump to any conclusions on this one until i hear a more reasonable explaination from amy herself.

    Mayo 2007
  • Catlike

    WTF! Stop tagging this as gothic. This is just your everyday metal bullshit.

    Mayo 2007
  • JucrazyBr

    YYYeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaHHHHh!!!!

    Mayo 2007
  • Karkalla

    I can't believe John and Rocky left. -is in shock-

    Mayo 2007
  • manda11

    Amy was the only one signed to the label ever since Ben left, so technically it is a solo project. Everyone else that has been in the band since Ben left have just been hired musicians. Unfortunate truth. And it's stupid when people judge Amy when they don't know her. I certainly don't like her public persona ever since TOD was released, but I'm not going to say she's an all-around bad person...

    Mayo 2007
  • aLLunderME

    EvaneScencE... I love it!! Thanks for come to Brazil. =)

    Mayo 2007
  • chukemene

    so sad....

    Mayo 2007
  • coobymx

    I love you Amy Lee/Evanescence! :*

    Mayo 2007
  • argmda

    She should do a solo career...

    Mayo 2007
  • jaum_

    The current situation of the band is so ridiculous. -.-'

    Mayo 2007
  • DjLf

    Wow. There goes my band.

    Mayo 2007
  • milkxcarton

    AVRIL LAVIGNE SIMILAR TO EVANESCENCE!!! WTF?!?!

    Mayo 2007
  • Braddley

    Fuck Amy Lee!

    Mayo 2007
  • Bozfly

    Amy Lee even sucks more than the music she and her backing band made.

    Mayo 2007
  • Tipheret

    Bah, Amy Lee the diva.

    Mayo 2007
  • SparklingGray

    OOh, yay! Ima top listener!

    Mayo 2007
  • akirabomb

    Amy Lee: John and Rocky were in Evanescence for four years and we shared some great times together playing live, but they were ready to move on and so we have parted ways. ... So she fired him? Riiiiigh.

    Mayo 2007
  • pepeleches

    claro que es a very strong posibility. si siempre tocan lo mismo se acaban aburriendo. extraño es que no lo hayan hecho ya. Bye.

    Mayo 2007
  • manda11

    All actual news regarding this is in this thread on EvThreads: click here Evanescence aren't splitting up.

    Mayo 2007
  • LizzArsenic

    Oh god. I'll kill Amy Lee. How could she fired John and let Rocky go ? I hate her.

    Mayo 2007
  • Moomino

    amy lee may as well be a solo artist anyway...no one ever seems to take any notice of the rest of the band

    Mayo 2007
  • vaguerant

    Don't feel bad, guys, it's the nature of mass-produced crap that it falls apart.

    Mayo 2007
  • xtimetowastexx

    oh god i hope they dont break up...but its a very strong possibility. =[

    Mayo 2007
  • samantha_666

    Ev was the first rock band i loved. And i'm so confused now.. don't know what to think or what to believe in. Maybe the best thing now for Ev is to split up officially:(

    Mayo 2007
  • blindedbyguns

    the band went through a lot on the past years, but i don't think nothing compares to this current crisis. not even when ben left. it's so so so sad to see evanescence falling apart this way...

    Mayo 2007
  • Metal_Giselle

    I'm done with the band, ok you can't call it a band, amy should renaim it and call it Amy Lee and other band members *Roll Eyes*

    Mayo 2007
  • akirabomb

    dolbinau said: Anyway, as I was saying Amy Lee is the most important thing in this band, period. Do you honestly think that Amy would have reached the level of success she has enjoy with Evanescence on her own? She would not have reached the level without former band members, Ben and David.

    Mayo 2007
  • bleedingblack

    :(

    Mayo 2007
  • jenny101

    They need to higher MachineGun Smith- This is they guy right here: http://youtube.com/watch?v=S0Ji4ITlo5Y

    Mayo 2007
  • FrozenInside

    I had sensed that would happen. I bought my copy of THE OPEN DOOR on iTunes and it came with a bonus video. An interview with the band, and if you notice, there is tension/hostility in the group. You can always tell. When Amy talks, the guys are just like rolling their eyes, and when the one of the guys talks, Amy was has a similar facial expression. Sad, but it happens. :( John is hott. :(

    Mayo 2007
  • akirabomb

    Rumour had it she's always been like this. The track record of people leaving the band speaks for itself, don't you think?

    Mayo 2007
  • coobymx

    Oh, well, I'll wait for what Amy has to say...

    Mayo 2007