Punk music » Debates

who is the most influencial punk person?

 
  • who is the most influencial punk person?

    brad nowell.
    henry rollins.
    iggy pop.

    ^^^I didn't just say that.^^^
  • iggy pop is probably the most influential person on the list but my favorite one on there is brad nowell

    • [Usuario eliminado] escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 27 Sep 2006, 16:30
    Joe Strummer
    Ian MacKaye?

    Mmm, it's pretty much impossible when you think of all the influential punk bands.

  • yes.

    sublime is still a masive influence today especially to kids around where i live where reggae is big.

    ^^^I didn't just say that.^^^
  • mikenobody said:
    sublime is still a masive influence today especially to kids around where i live where reggae is big.

    reggae isnt big here you fucktard. we live in fucking suburbian michigan. Fuck you mike. Just fuck you. twice for every stupid thing you've ever said. which is about 494875982387428372308957095873240572387 fucks.

  • strummer, mackaye, d. boon, mike watt, rollins, milo aukerman, bill stevensen, oh and THE RAMONES


    BUT NOT BILLY JO GREEN DAY HE IS A FUCKHEAD LOL I HATE HIM AND AM TOO PUNK TO BE LISTEN TO POP-PUNK FAGGOT PUSSY SHIT LIKE HIM!!! I LISTEN TO ANTI-FLAG LIKE A TRUPUNX MAN.

  • iwasneveryoung said:
    strummer, mackaye, d. boon, mike watt, rollins, milo aukerman, bill stevensen, oh and THE RAMONES


    BUT NOT BILLY JO GREEN DAY HE IS A FUCKHEAD LOL I HATE HIM AND AM TOO PUNK TO BE LISTEN TO POP-PUNK FAGGOT PUSSY SHIT LIKE HIM!!! I LISTEN TO ANTI-FLAG LIKE A TRUPUNX MAN.

    dont forget Whore-Hey and his casualties

    • bozemblem escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 15 Oct 2006, 22:07
    sid vicious
    greg graffin
    iggy pop

    We only live a day, but it's brilliant anyways.
  • This question could have two meanings, which makes it difficult(impossible?) to answer. Who was the most influential to you personally or on the scene as a whole? And then it could go even deeper as to say that a person or group that was influential might not have been punks in anyway, maybe precursors, or inspirations to the movement itself.

    For me persoanlly, the man in punk rock who has influenced me immensely was Joe Strummer. The way he wrote, the way he lived, the way he thought, he amazed me time and again.

    Other bands have inlfuenced me greater I believe, with more politically charged lyrics or what have you, but, he was one of the first and has stuck with me the longest.

  • johnny thunders is my biggest influence

    • HC-Ixnay escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 16 Abr 2007, 13:51
    Ian MacKaye
    Henry Rollins
    Greg Ginn
    Milo Aukerman
    Bill Stevensen
    Dave Dictor

    ...squeeze to warm and ribs stab heart. Now the taste of my teeth reminds me, have I called you today? yesterday I called you never...
    • 80sfraud escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 23 Abr 2007, 4:14
    Ian Mackaye pretty much invented alternative music.

    RICHARD HELL come on people.
    Mike Watt
    D. Boon
    Joe Strummer
    H.R.

  • I totally agree with RyanDamage about Joe Strummer,

    • RL91 escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 29 Abr 2007, 20:43
    Jello Biafra, Ian Mackaye, Joey Ramone

    • fagan89 escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 30 Abr 2007, 18:22
    RyanDamage said...

    16 Oct 2006, 1:28
    This question could have two meanings, which makes it difficult(impossible?) to answer. Who was the most influential to you personally or on the scene as a whole? And then it could go even deeper as to say that a person or group that was influential might not have been punks in anyway, maybe precursors, or inspirations to the movement itself.

    For me persoanlly, the man in punk rock who has influenced me immensely was Joe Strummer. The way he wrote, the way he lived, the way he thought, he amazed me time and again.

    Other bands have inlfuenced me greater I believe, with more politically charged lyrics or what have you, but, he was one of the first and has stuck with me the longest.


    ENOUGH SAID!

    bollocks!!!!!
    • roghe escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 30 Abr 2007, 23:27
    stiv bators.

    • [Usuario eliminado] escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 1 May 2007, 19:17
    HC-Ixnay said:
    Ian MacKaye
    Henry Rollins
    Greg Ginn
    Milo Aukerman
    Bill Stevensen
    Dave Dictor

    Despite Henry Rollins being painfully overrated, I agree with your list. How about Greg Graffin and Brett Gurewitz...

  • you dont need two bad religion people surely?

  • you dont need two bad religion people surely?

    • [Usuario eliminado] escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 1 May 2007, 20:05
    HC-Ixnay said:
    Rollins being painfully overrated, I agree with your list. How about Greg Graffin and Brett Gurewitz...


    SPOT THE IRONY!

    • [Usuario eliminado] escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 1 May 2007, 23:15
    spudnik700 said:
    HC-Ixnay said:
    Rollins being painfully overrated, I agree with your list. How about Greg Graffin and Brett Gurewitz...


    SPOT THE IRONY!

    Rollins wasn't even with Black Flag when they were tolerable (not good). The day he writes a song remotely comparable to the works of the aforementioned members of BR, I'll shut my mouth.

  • tylerb1085 said:
    spudnik700 said:
    HC-Ixnay said:
    Rollins being painfully overrated, I agree with your list. How about Greg Graffin and Brett Gurewitz...


    SPOT THE IRONY!

    Rollins wasn't even with Black Flag when they were tolerable (not good). The day he writes a song remotely comparable to the works of the aforementioned members of BR, I'll shut my mouth.

    Bad Religion may have better lyrics, content-wise, but Black Flag is forever superior musically. actually, Flag's lyrics are always more fun and sing-a-long-able, and they didn't stick around over ten years past their prime just to put out mediocre, preachy records.

  • Henry Rollins is a fucking asshole. He may be influential I suppose but he's a fucking dick.

    • 80sfraud escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 3 May 2007, 4:38
    youd be a dick too if you were that depressed and crazy.

    • [Usuario eliminado] escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 3 May 2007, 18:14
    the music's good so who cares?
    bad brains are a bunch of fucking homophobic cunts, but shit the music is good.

Los usuarios anónimos no pueden escribir mensajes. Para participar en los foros inicia sesión o crea una cuenta.