I Hate Music Snobs » Debates

Users who "snob" themselves

 
    • R3CURSION escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 17 Ene 2012, 21:30

    Users who "snob" themselves

    Lately, I've noticed a trend where Last.fm users are using their “about me” section to apologize for their taste (or perceived lack thereof). These “taste disclaimers” range from brief blurbs to lengthy diatribes, but most of them can be reduced to one of the following:

    1. “My taste is diverse and well cultivated, but don't deny me my guilty pleasures!”
    2. “I love pop, but I listen to serious music too. Don't you dare forget it!”
    3. “I listen to whatever the hell I want, and I don't care what you think of me!”

    I have to admit that I find most of these disclaimers entertaining and always stop to read them, but I still wonder why they're so common. Does a big part of the Last.fm userbase really feel their taste needs apologizing for? Most of the profiles I've seen this kind of thing on show quite a bit of balance --- I have a hard time believing they've ever gotten flak for their taste.

    Also, of the three options above, #2 strikes me as the strangest. These users have an interesting self-snobbery thing going on, where pop music is inherently shameful and its presence somehow discredits the other more “respectable" music they listen to. Honestly, if you like something, just play it! There's no need to apologize, especially since honestly tracking one's own taste is a big part of what Last.fm is supposed to be about. (Or is it?)

    Thoughts?

  • It's one thing to explain why their taste is so diverse but it must be a problem if they can't even stand up for the music they like. It's like they are afraid of getting comments like "your taste suck" from random users. Actually I don't know - if they listen to music they find embarrassing themselves then why would they get respect for liking good music? :)

    • ashiyal escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 20 Ene 2012, 8:58
    Seems to me it makes sense, if they're not being too serious about it... sometimes you might think you'll never like X song or Y band, you think it's really bad (to you), but you find yourself liking it one day, I understand how that might make one self-conscious. So one might think "hahahah omg I can't believe I enjoy this stuff, oh well, still think it's crap but I like it".

    Actually being seriously DEFENSIVE about it is weird, I agree.... you'd have to have some serious self-consciousness problem, with an elitist image to uphold lol. Being music snobs to begin with. Can you imagine it? It'd be like a homophobe realizing they're gay "zomg I like THIS?!? What ever will my metalhead friends think?!"
    I hope they're mostly young people, maybe they'll grow out of it.

  • Not sure what's wrong with #3. Aside from the phrasing you used to get the "I know you are, but what am I?" tone.

    I mean, this entire group is pretty much about how we just want to listen to what we like and how we're tired of the people that think we give a shit if they don't like what we do.

    So I totally understand that one.

    • macychick escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 5 Feb 2012, 19:39
    "So one might think "hahahah omg I can't believe I enjoy this stuff, oh well, still think it's crap but I like it". "

    That's pretty much what I think whenever I hear Ke$ha. She sounds like a total amateur but some of her songs are catchy as hell!

    That guinea pig in my avatar? His name is Benny.
    • Randwer escribió...
    • Usuario
    • 12 Feb 2012, 16:13
    Sometimes I'm astonished, why I listen to The Toten Crackhuren im Kofferraum and Katzenpisse and enjoy their stuff.^^

  • Yeah, I'm a number 3 person in general xD (Not on my about me section though.) Don't understand how that's snobbing yourself though. There are certain types of music people snob and even if you like those types of music, you can still recognise them and predict that people will sneer. I mean, cheesy pop music and anything mainstream gets slated. I don't have to snob it to notice that.

    I understand that it's sometimes not very deep, but I don't only like deep things. I like those songs for other reasons, like they make me happy or they remind me of when I was younger or I just like reminding myself that I'm not a snobby-hipster-troll.


    Hi. Come follow me on Twitter
  • I do snob over my own taste sometimes, like when a Glee song comes on my station, I'm like "Am I really gonna listen to this?". I like about half of Glee songs about half the time, but I am kind of tired of it being at the top of my charts when there are so many artists I listen to and like more. There are just so many Glee songs, and some of them are really good covers. And some are overproduced crap. But anyone who thinks there are no talented singers on Glee and ALL the covers are Kidz Bop quality shit hasn't heard every song off Glee. It's not everyone's thing. I get that. But some of these singers were on Broadway and have better voices than most singers out there.

  • Candyheart33 said:

    I understand that it's sometimes not very deep, but I don't only like deep things. I like those songs for other reasons, like they make me happy or they remind me of when I was younger or I just like reminding myself that I'm not a snobby-hipster-troll.


    This! Haha.

  • I can listen to extremely discerning electro-acoustic music till i'm blue in the face. I can cultivate an interest in the more obscure corners of industrial music till the cows come home. One can witch house oneself till they're sore. I can even have scrobble the odd 20 minute free jazz epic to impress the beret wearing WIRE reading masses. None of this alters the fact I love Operation Blade (Bass In The Place...) by Public Domain.



    (we all have guilty pleasures, but some should make us feel more guilty than others ;3)

    "If Jeremy Kyle broadcast from chernobyl, it would explain why his guests all look like decomposing farm animals." ~ One of DaddyPobbin's friends
Los usuarios anónimos no pueden escribir mensajes. Para participar en los foros inicia sesión o crea una cuenta.